Most Ordered
Famous Pounder Cheesesteak Sub
An entire pound of chipped sirloin, seasoned to perfection on the whole! And a half pound on a half sub!
$9.65
Funnel Cake Fries
Funnel cake fries topped with powdered sugar.
$6.50
Turkey Breast Sub
$7.25
Italian Sub
Capicola, baked ham, salami, provolone cheese.
$7.25
French Fries
$5.83
Bacon Cheddar Ranch Fries
A pile of french fries topped with hot golden cheese, real bacon and ranch dressing! It's a whole meal!
$8.95
Bacon Cheddar Ranch Tots
A pile of tater tots topped with hot golden cheese, real bacon and ranch dressing! It's a whole meal!
$8.95
Three Cheese Steak Sub
Our Famous Cheesesteak with American, Provolone and Aged Cheddar Sauce! Any toppings you would like! So cheesy and delicious! Garden will be on top of this and cheese on the very bottom. It is very juicy so please know this ahead, since the cheese is on the bottom!
$11.75
Mozzarella Sticks
$5.83
Deep Fried Pierogies
Deep-fried Mrs. T's cheddar and potato pierogies.
$5.83
Ham Sub
$7.25
Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$5.95
Italian Hoagie Pizza
An amazing creation! Italian hoagie meat (capicola, ham, salami and provolone) on a pizza. Simple and so delicious! Top it with all the hoagie toppings you want, it's great with sauce, mayo, hot peppers, whatever you like!
$17.95
Breakfast Sandwiches
Bacon, Egg & Cheese English Muffin Breakfast
$6.00
Steak, Egg & Cheese Bagel Breakfast
$6.50
Steak, Egg & Cheese English Muffin Breakfast
$6.25
Sausage, Egg & Cheese Breakfast
$6.00
Finger Foods
Chicken Tenders Basket
Large white meat chicken tenders and a large order of french fries.
$11.60
Beer Battered Haddock Basket
Beer battered haddock served with a pile of french fries and a side of tarter sauce.
$12.66
French Fries
$5.83
French Fries with Cheese
$6.36
Bacon Cheddar Ranch Fries
A pile of french fries topped with hot golden cheese, real bacon and ranch dressing! It's a whole meal!
$8.95
Bacon Cheddar Ranch Tots
A pile of tater tots topped with hot golden cheese, real bacon and ranch dressing! It's a whole meal!
$8.95
Tater Tots
$5.83
Tater Tots with Cheese
$6.36
Chicken Nuggets
$4.25
Chicken Tenders
Large breaded tenders!
$6.75
Plain Wing Dings
Breaded drums and flats, hot or plain.
$5.50
Hot Wing Dings
Breaded drums and flats, hot or plain.
$5.50
Mozzarella Sticks
$5.83
Fried Mushrooms
$5.50
Fried Cauliflower
$5.83
Fried Pickle Chips
$5.50
Mac & Cheese Bites
$5.83
Corn Nuggets
$5.50
Onion Rings
$5.50
Cheese Curds
$5.83
Pizza Logs
$6.95
Deep Fried Pierogies
Deep-fried Mrs. T's cheddar and potato pierogies.
$5.83
Broccoli & Cheddar Bites
Breaded & deep fried.
$5.83
Curly Fries
Seasoned curly fries.
$6.36
Curly Fries with Cheese
Seasoned curly fries with a side of cheese whiz.
$6.79
Deep Fried Oreos
Gooey pancake battered deep fried Oreos topped with powdered sugar.
$7.50
Hot Wings
$15.37
Funnel Cake Fries
Funnel cake fries topped with powdered sugar.
$6.50
Homemade Cheesesteak Eggrolls
Homemade cheesesteak eggrolls. If you would like buffalo chicken please specify in notes.
$9.48
Homemade Chicken Cheesesteak Eggrolls
Homemade cheesesteak eggrolls. If you would like buffalo chicken please specify in notes.
$9.57
Shrimp Basket
Fried shrimp with fries.
$12.60
With A Fork
Chef Salad
Ham, turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers, black olives, hard-boiled egg.
$10.50
Tuna Salad
Tuna on a bed of lettuce, tomato and onion with provolone cheese.
$7.50
Chicken Cheesesteak Salad
Lettuce, tomato and fried onion topped with 8 oz. of seasoned chicken and American cheese.
$9.00
Cheesesteak Salad
Lettuce, tomato and fried onion topped with 8 oz. of seasoned sirloin and American cheese.
$8.75
Grilled Chicken Salad
8 oz. of delicious grilled chicken breast strips atop lettuce, tomato, and onion topped with a shredded mozzarella and provolone cheese blend and your choice of dressing!
$8.75
Tossed Salad
Lettuce, tomato and onion with provolone cheese and your choice of dressing.
$6.95
Chips
Middleswarth Chips
We reserve the right to substitute if the choice is unavailable.
$1.19
New & Special Menu Items
Bacon Steak N' Chicken Hoagie
A giant portion of real bacon, our famous steak and chicken made with whiz. Any toppings you like. If you would like a different cheese please indicate.
$12.19
Pounder Cheesesteak Pizza
A pound of our famous seasoned sirloin steak atop of a fresh baked Lycoming Bakery pizza shell! Choose any toppings you desire, whether it be in the garden with mayo, or with sauce, green peppers, fried onions and mushrooms! Or whatever you dream up! If you don't see it in the options here, put it in the notes!
$17.95
Stromboli Wrap
Choose your wrap flavor. Please add in the notes if you would like white, wheat, tomato or spinach wrap. If you don't specify you will receive a white wrap. A wrap stuffed full with salami, capicola, ham, pepperoni, provolone, mozzarella and sauce. Baked in the oven to perfection! So good and a healthier alternative to the traditional stromboli while definitely filling you up likely with leftovers! If you would like extra sauce on the side, of would like to remove any of the meats please add that in the notes.
$10.50
Funnel Cake Fries
An order of a funnel cake fries topped with powdered sugar!
$5.83
The Carson
Half pound of our famous steak, topped with crisp fries, golden aged whiz and ketchup on a wrap! It's amazing!
$22.20
Sandwiches
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Chicken filet with mild sauce, ranch and American cheese.
$9.50
Chicken Cordon Bleu Sandwich
Chicken filet with Swiss cheese melted over ham.
$9.50
Reuben Sandwich
$9.50
Cauliflower & Broccoli Sandwich Thins
Ham & Turkey Combo Sandwich
$11.75
Roast Beef Sandwich
$11.75
Canadian Bacon Cheesesteak Sandwich
Our famous pounder cheesesteak mixed with Canadian bacon flavor bursting.
$14.75
Bacon Cheeseburger
On a hoagie roll half or whole.
$14.75
Double Cheeseburger
$15.37
Big R Sandwich
It's huge! A 24 oz. pile of ham, turkey, roast beef, cheese.
$16.75
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich
Half a pound of seasoned white meat chicken.
$12.19
Famous Cheesesteak Sandwich
Half a pound of our famous seasoned sirloin beef!
$12.19
Cold, Cosmo Hoagies & Wraps
Veggie Sub
All vegetables any way you want it! Add options below!
$6.25
Cheese Sub
Provolone cheese only.
$7.25
Regular Sub
Dutch loaf, chopped ham, salami, provolone cheese.
$7.25
Italian Sub
Capicola, baked ham, salami, provolone cheese.
$7.25
Turkey Breast Sub
$7.25
Ham Sub
$7.25
Tuna Sub
Our Tuna is made with mayo only. No onions, celery or spices added.
$7.25
Meatball Sub
Made with Thompsons beef meatballs, Ma Mileto's original recipe homemade sauce topped with Parmesan cheese. If made as a cosmo, topped with provolone cheese. If you would like a different kind of cheese please indicate in the notes.
$7.25
Canadian Bacon Sub
$7.25
BLT Sub
Bacon, lettuce and tomato with all the fillings you like!
$7.25
Ham & Turkey Combo Sub
$8.50
Roast Beef Sub
$8.50
The "Big R" Sub
It's huge! 24 oz. of meat! A pile of ham, turkey and roast beef, plus the cheese.
$13.25
Pizza Rolla Sub
Just like the name...Pizza on a roll!
$7.68
Beer Battered Haddock Sub
8 oz. on a half. 16 oz. on the whole.
$9.00
Grinder Sub
A regular sub with all the fillings and more provolone cheese on top toasted to perfection.
$7.75
Chicken Parm Sub
Please add in notes if you want breaded of grilled chicken breast! Otherwise you will receive grilled. 8oz of chicken on a half and 16oz of chicken on a whole. On a toasted garlic hoagie roll with mozzarella cheese, homemade sauce and pesto. If you do not want pesto, please add that in the notes.
$8.50
Mixed Cheese Sub
Perfect blend of provolone, swiss and american cheeses! Tastes amazing as a cosmo!
$8.30
Don Father Sub
Italian sub cosmo with pepper jack cheese.
$8.50
From The Grill
Famous Pounder Cheesesteak Sub
An entire pound of chipped sirloin, seasoned to perfection on the whole! And a half pound on a half sub!
$8.75
Three Cheese Steak Sub
Our Famous Cheesesteak with American, Provolone and Aged Cheddar Sauce! Any toppings you would like! So cheesy and delicious! Garden will be on top of this and cheese on the very bottom. It is very juicy so please know this ahead, since the cheese is on the bottom!
$11.75
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak Sub
8 oz. on a half. 16 oz. on the whole. We use Franks Red Hot!
$8.75
Hot Sausage Sub
Spicy Italian sausage chopped to perfection! 10 oz. on a half. 20 oz. on the whole.
$8.75
The Carson Sub
Half pound of our famous steak, topped with crisp fries, golden aged whiz and ketchup on a wrap! It's amazing!
$8.75
Bacon Cheeseburger
On a hoagie roll! Half or whole!
$12.25
Cheeseburger
8 oz. on a half. 16 oz. on the whole. we chop our burger meat to fit the hoagie roll.
$8.75
The Tango Sub
Chicken & beef cheesesteaks.
$9.26
Taco Cheesesteak
$9.00
Wraps
Famous Cheesesteak Wrap
A half pound of chipped sirloin steak seasoned to perfection.
$8.49
Cheeseburger Wrap
10 oz. of seasoned ground beef.
$11.75
Bacon Cheeseburger Wrap
Ground seasoned burger mixed with real bacon pieces, so juicy!
$14.75
Canadian Bacon Cheesesteak Wrap
Our famous cheesesteak grilled with Canadian bacon.....flavor bursting.
$14.75
Hot Sausage Wrap
10 oz. hot Italian sausage patties chopped to fit a hoagie roll or wrap.
$9.39
Veggie Wrap
$5.89
Ham Wrap
$7.09
Turkey Breast Wrap
$7.09
Tuna Wrap
Our Tuna is made with mayo only. No onions, celery or added spices.
$7.09
Italian Wrap
Capicola, baked ham, salami and provolone cheese.
$7.09
Regular Wrap
Dutch loaf, chopped ham, salami and provolone cheese.
$7.09
Ham & Turkey Combo Wrap
$11.75
BLT Wrap
Bacon, lettuce and tomato and whatever other toppings you would like!
$7.09
Roast Beef Wrap
$11.75
The 'Big R' Wrap
It's huge! 24 oz. of ham, turkey, and roast beef plus the cheese.
$16.75
Mixed Cheese Wrap
Swiss, American and provolone cheese.
$7.39
Cheese Wrap
Provolone cheese only.
$7.09
Hard Salami Wrap
$7.09
Footlong Hot Dogs
Chili Cheese Footlong Hot Dog
Chili cheese footlong hot dog. Home-made chili and yellow shredded cheese.
$7.50
Footlong Hot Dog
$5.75
Kids Meals
Kid's Nugget Basket
Chicken nuggets and tater tots or fries meal.
$7.88
Kid's Chicken Tenders & Fries
$8.47
Kid's Grilled Cheese & Fries
$7.47
Kid's Chicken Nuggets & Fries
$7.88
Beverages
Valley Farms Chocolate Milk
$2.39
Soda
$2.39
Brisk Iced Tea
$2.39
Water
$1.79
Catering Sub Tray
Sub Trays in Multiple Sizes Catering
Indicate what kinds specifically you would like in the notes please. Small Feeds 8 - 12 (3 whole subs) - $43.50; Medium Feeds 12 - 16 (4 whole subs) - $58.00; Large Feeds 16 - 20 (5 whole subs) - $72.50; XL Feeds 20 - 24 (6 whole subs) - $87.00; Add $14.50 for each additional sub. (All above feeding numbers are approximate and we cannot guarantee that your guests will not eat more than expected. Thank you for your understanding on this.) Choose any combination of the following: Ham, Turkey Breast, Regular, Italian or Tuna. Provolone, American, Swiss or Pepper Jack Cheese. Cheesesteak, Roast Beef, Ham/Tky Combo is an additional $3.75 per whole sub. Trays Include: Homemade Oil, Hot Peppers and Mayonnaise on the side. Lettuce and Tomato on the side is an additional $2.50 per order.
$43.50
Mileto's Sub Shop and Pizza in Newberry
Enjoy Williamsport's best pizzas at some of the top pizza restaurants in the area. Mileto's Sub Shop and Pizza in Newberry is one of the most popular in Williamsport. Try their pizza, and you'll soon see why. Try some of Williamsport's best dishes at independent pizzerias in the city. Find new favorites and get a taste of what Williamsport has to offer. Add french fries to your pizza for a more satisfying meal. It's a great addition to any pizza from Mileto's Sub Shop and Pizza in Newberry. Mileto's Sub Shop and Pizza in Newberry has been a Slice partner since 2025. They've been serving the local community for a while now, so you can rely on them providing great pizza. Call ahead and get curbside pickup at Mileto's Sub Shop and Pizza in Newberry. It's never been easier to get hot, fresh pizza to go. You can pay by credit card at Mileto's Sub Shop and Pizza in Newberry. That makes it easy to get your pizza as quickly as possible.
2127 W 4th St
Williamsport, PA 17701
9:30 AM-6:30 PM
Full Hours